Here at The Home Insurance Guide, we know how serious a decision insurance is. It’s our mission to help renters make the best coverage choice for the lowest price possible -- because we believe that knowing is saving.

We recognize how complicated the search for a new renters insurance policy can be, but it just doesn’t have to be this way. With the aid of our proprietary algorithm, we aim to save both your money and your time. Can we find you a renters insurance policy that’s both high quality and affordable? Yes. Can we get you your results within seconds, so you don't have to spend hours researching on your own? Yes. Do we rate and review only the best insurance companies so you know you’re guaranteed quality? Yes.

With so many renters insurance options available, finding the best one -- one that keeps your home and possessions safe without costing you a fortune -- is difficult, to say the least. With so much information floating around online, where should you look and who can you trust? This is what we hope to change. We’ve designed our own proprietary algorithm that can search through all of the top renters insurance options in mere seconds.

Our Methodology

How do we get such fantastic deals? Our team has decades of combined experience working directly in the insurance field. We’ve spent hours researching renters insurance providers, analyzing policies, and interviewing agents in order to understand exactly what’s out there. Using our findings, we’ve now built a proprietary ranking system. We take into consideration several factors, including cost, claims handling, and general customer service, to bring you only the best providers on the market today.

Besides our deep understanding of the insurance industry, we also have years of experience working with and creating insurance-focused technology, which has allowed us to develop our own proprietary algorithm to work within the renters insurance field. Our algorithm behaves just as the usual insurance company’s algorithm would, but with one major caveat -- ours is here to benefit the renters, not the insurers.

Insurance companies use their algorithms to determine how much risk is associated with each policy they sell, which guides their insurance-selling decisions. Their risk assessments change constantly as both data and conditions change, which explains why insurance rates appear so out of control for the average consumer. Essentially, the rate a company offers you is the rate that’s available at that very moment – if you checked again tomorrow, it might already have changed.

This lack of consistency makes keeping an eye on the renters insurance market absolutely necessary. Otherwise, you end up overpaying. Shopping around for a policy is time-consuming and often confusing, however, and this is why most people avoid it altogether. Here's where our service comes in, though. By answering just a few relevant questions on our site, we will find the best renters insurance options available for you and have them sent to you within seconds. With our help, you won’t have to worry about overpaying because you’ll have all the best options in one easy place.

All combined, our reviews, rankings, and ratings will save you money, time, and stress as you shop for renters insurance. We will match you with only the most relevant and affordable providers. If you want to read more information on the companies you are interested in, you can click Read Full Review, and when you’re ready to start looking at quotes, just click View Rates.

Renters insurance poses a unique insurance challenge because the policyholders do not own the actual building they live in, and thus are not necessarily responsible to protect it. Their possessions and their ability to live a quality life, however, are dependent on said building staying in good shape. Additionally, renters do have some responsibility to treat the space their renting relatively well. With all of this in mind, what exactly does renters coverage do?

• Personal property coverage: Just as the name implies, this covers the possessions you keep within your home. If your building is affected by an unfortunate incident such as a fire, a bad storm, or vandalism. Most insurers ask policyholders to document all their possessions before taking out a policy to ensure fair payback. Keep in mind that a roommate’s possessions cannot be included under your policy -- they will need their own policy if they want coverage too.
• Personal liability and medical bills: If someone is accidentally injured while at your place, renters insurance can help cover the associated costs. Potential causes of injury can include a dog bite, or even damage to the building that you yourself caused while out (such as a housefire caused by food left on the stove). Both medical and legal costs can be covered.
• Temporary living expenses: If your building becomes uninhabitable, your renters insurance can help cover the cost of needing to live elsewhere temporarily. This must be caused by a covered event.

The owner of your building is required to purchase and maintain their own insurance policy, which will cover damage to the building in the many events, such as covered natural disasters. Don’t expect this to cover all of your needs as well, however. Though it may or may not be required of you as a tenant, having your own renters insurance allows you a much greater peace of mind, as it ensures that your stuff and your lifestyle are protected, no matter what happens to the building itself.

Renters Insurance Company Ratings & Reviews

The Home Insurance Guide uses several methods to form our proprietary renters insurance rankings, with one of the most important factors being our Agent Survey. We talked directly with as many independent insurance agents as we could in order to understand which insurers offer the most value overall.

Agents with years of experience in the renters and home insurance industries, with genuine interest in helping clients to find the best policy for their needs, and who work independently from any one insurance company tend to have the deepest insight on how insurers work and what coverages renters need. By talking to these experts, we were able to determine the top carriers in the field. It’s important to remember that agents are usually incentivized to retain customers, a goal most easily met by pairing customers with the best possible company from the start. We chose to interview agents because our goal is similar -- to provide our site visitors with the knowledge necessary for them to shop smart and pick the best policy for their needs. Largely due to the insights we came across through this Agent Survey, we were able to piece together our official renters insurance carrier rankings.

Our Agent Survey is also the basis of our official company reviews. Each year, we evaluate and summarize the key benefits of select renters insurance providers in order to bring you updated information. Our 2024 review focuses on pricing, breadth of offering (defined as geographic coverage and product line), and the online customer experience. Looking at this combination of factors, we’ve narrowed down the best home insurance providers so you don’t have to spend hours researching on your own. We reviewed the following companies:

Insurance Carriers

1. Allstate Insurance Review
2. Esurance Insurance Review
3. Hippo Insurance Review
4. Kin Insurance Review
5. Lemonade Insurance Review
6. Progressive Insurance Review
7. Travelers Insurance Review

Insurance Brokers or Insurance Agencies

1. Blue Sky Insurance Review
2. Compare Insurance Review
3. Home Insurance King Insurance Review
4. Insurance Rates for Less Insurance Review
5. Kelly Klee Insurance Review
6. Select Quote Insurance Review
7. Young Alfred Insurance Review

Home Insurance Help When You Need It